Categorized | Sam Says

Possible Arson Destroys Chattanooga GLBT-serving Church

Posted on 26 August 2009

glbt pride
On Sunday, August 23, the St. Elmo United Methodist church on St. Elmo Avenue in Chattanooga went up in flames.

Church members suspect that hate had something to do with what the 70 federal, state, and local officials are investigating.

The ATF is investigating the fire because any case of arson in a church may be considered a hate crime, which is a federal offense, and because the church building, which was built in 1921, is worth $1.5 million.

St. Elmo resident Charles King told Chattanooga News Channel 12 that “KKK” was spray painted on the church’s sign just months ago.

St. Elmo Church is known for its liberal congregation and is known for serving the GLBT community.

ATF Assistant Special Agent Steven Gerido said in a press conference, “We don’t know how the fire got started. We know the origin and that’s all we know.”

St. Elmo Church displays the motto “Open Hearts. Open Minds. Open Doors.” on its homepage.

The Department of Justice says, “The purveyors of hate use explosives, arson, weapons, vandalism, physical violence, and verbal threats of violence to instill fear in their victims, leaving them vulnerable to more attacks and feeling alienated, helpless, suspicious and fearful.”

It is very possible that this is a case of arson, and St. Elmo’s experience with KKK vandalism suggests the possibility of a hate crime.

I hope that the community members affected by the St. Elmo church fire do not become vulnerable, suspicious and fearful with their future community outreach (especially with their GLBT outreach). That is what the perpetrators of hate want most.

Many people do not realize that the KKK is still marching, targeting GLBT people in addition to other minority groups.

With events like the fire at St. Elmo raising people’s consciousness (not just gay people’s) about hate in Chattanooga, an organization like CommunityNashville would be beneficial in Chattanooga.

CommunityNashville has an excellent model for encouraging and building just communities while fighting bias, bigotry and racism in Middle Tennessee.

7 Responses to “Possible Arson Destroys Chattanooga GLBT-serving Church”

  1. Scott Medley says:

    Response to “Possible Arson Destroys Chattanooga GLBT serving church”

    Hello, My name is Scott Medley and I am chairmain of Trustees at St. Elmo United Methodist Church. I must tell you that information in this article is simply not factual. Our church members absolutely DO NOT suspect that this is a hate crime of arson. St. Elmo United Methodist Church is NOT “known” for it’s liberal congregation. We are neither considered “liberal” or “conservative. We ARE known to be a “diverse” congregation. We may be known by some as serving the GLBT community, but we are absolutely known for serving anyone and everyone who chooses to worship with us or seeks our ministries. “KKK” was never painted on our church sign. It was painted in two places on the rear of our building. This was very faded and reported by one of our older members that it could have been there as long as 15 years ago. We absolutely do display the motto “Open Heart. Open Minds. Open Doors on our homepage. (which happens to be the motto of the Global United Methodist Denomination). It is NOT “very” possible that this is a case of arson. It is just one of 3 possible causes…accidental, undetermined or arson. We have never been targeted specifically for any of our ministries. We would just ask that you not sensationalize our recent loss. Please do not label our church as specifically ministering to any one group. We minister to all. If you want accurate information regarding St. Elmo UMC and it’s ministries, it can be obtained from our Pastor, Rev. Mark Dowell, myself, the Holston Conference Chattanooga District Office or state and local ATF and fire officials. Any information received for any other sources may or may not be correct. Respectfully, Scott Medley

  2. Sam Jones says:

    I apologize if my blog post has cotributed to a distraction for the leaders of St. Elmo Church while they work to rebuild their church.

    It appears that everyone in the media covering this story has taken this same angle.

    Being that I am on the GLBT news beat, I covered it from the perspective relevant to my readers. I apologize to them if the string of observations appears “sensational.”

    Chattanooga News Channels 9 and 12 have sited St. Elmo Church for being “known” for its “liberal congregation” and for ministering to “gays and lesbians.” Labels are difficult to shake-off, but these labels are salient in the media coverage of this church’s story.

    I stand by the original blog entry because it only stated a possibility. I used inductive reasoning to suggest that something is “possible,” and ususally induction results in conclusions that are “probable.” Please emphasize the term “Possible” in the title of the article.

    As for the resident source speaking to News Channel 12 about “KKK” being on the sign just months ago and suggesting suspicion among church members: I hope that St. Elmo Church can get News Channel 12 to retract and discredit him as a source.

    I am saddened that a fire has destroyed St. Elmo Church, and my sympathies are with the congregation. I pray that everyone can turn this tragedy into a community triumph with the will to rebuild and continue serving a higher purpose. I also pray that the investigators will find that this is not a case of arson or a hate-motivated crime.

  3. voip says:

    Nice to be stumbling up to your site again, it has been weeks for me. Well this is the article that i’ve been searching for so long. I can use this article to end my paper in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, fantastic share.

  4. sukienki says:

    Pomocne informacje warto zaglądać częściej :)


Leave a Reply

RSS O&AN Headlines

  • Photo Gallery: Nashville GLBT Chamber July 2010 Mixer
    Members and guests of the Nashville GLBT Chamber of Commerce met on July 23 at the Community Foundation of Middle Tennessee, where the Brooks Fund and many other philanthropic organizations maintain their offices. In addition to getting updates on... […]
  • Shakespeare in Centennial Park begins Aug. 19
    'Love's Labor's Lost' to get animated with birds, bees theme. This year's production is "Love's Labor's Lost," and will be set in the late 19th century to give a Victorian twist to the story. […]
  • Vanderbilt hosts HRC scholarship class
    Inaugural group launches mentorship program for religious, theological study. The last week of July is fairly quiet on college campuses, but the Human Rights Campaign got some conversations going at the Vanderbilt University Divinity School. […]